Lanny Horwitz was shot nine times in his Florida home on Sept. 30, 2011. There were two people in the house -- who pulled the trigger?
High school sweethearts Lanny Horwitz and Donna Carnevale, first and second from left, met in Buffalo, N,Y. Lanny's brother, Barry, far right, recalls many joyful memories in the years that followed, like this one at a costume party.
Watch: Love, Hate & Obsession